Back to Main Blog

Should isn't a rule, it's a fear signal.

Sep 18, 2026

"You should be out of bed by now, you'll miss the bus, you'll be late for school, I'll be late for work."

Nothing unusual about me screaming that up the stairs at my kids. I've said some version of that sentence a thousand times.

That said, they are always on time. Every single day, somehow, we make it. The should isn't describing what's actually happening. It's describing what I'm afraid might happen.

Because that word, should, isn't a rule. It's a sign.

You are not one single self reacting to your child. You are made up of parts. Part of you wants to stay calm. Part of you wants to shout back. Part of you has already vacated before the mayhem starts. Fear is one of those parts. It formed early, most likely in your own childhood, and it took on a job: keep you safe from a feeling it decided, a long time ago, was too much to handle. It's still running that job today, on a child who had nothing to do with where it came from.

The fear, named. Mine is a fear about time, about being late. I don't even know where it came from originally. I dream about it. Running, chasing my own tail, never quite making it.

The feeling it's hiding. Somewhere along the way I decided being late means one thing about me. Disorganised. Chaotic. Not on top of things. Can't cope. Failing. That's the feeling sitting underneath the fear, shame, plain and simple. Not being good enough.

I'm not the only one. Ask most women and you'll find some version of the same thing running underneath. Time and urgency are rarely just about the clock. They're about control. About being seen to be coping when you're quietly holding everything together on your own, unnoticed, and terrified of what happens the moment it shows. Late isn't just late. Late is the evidence. That's what the fear is actually protecting: not the school run, but whether you get to keep believing you're coping.

So when your fear part fires, it doesn't say "I'm scared." It disguises itself as a judgment about your child instead. You should be out of bed by now. He shouldn't shout. She shouldn't ignore me. It sounds like a reasonable standard. It isn't. It's your fear part, talking in the only language it has.

And should does something quietly costly. It moves the responsibility outside you, so their behaviour becomes the thing that has to change before you can feel okay. Which is backwards. What actually changes a child's behaviour is you being okay regardless. That's what gives them somewhere steady to land.

To be clear, this isn't about absorbing it. You're still allowed a boundary. We leave at eight. Shouting doesn't work for me. But there's a difference between a boundary set by your fear part and one set by you. One comes from panic, and your child feels the panic more than the boundary. The other comes from steadiness. Same words, sometimes. Completely different feeling underneath. That's the part your child is actually reading.

So here's the practice, and it's simple. Just start catching your shoulds.

Any time you hear yourself think or say a should about your child, stop and notice it. "You should be out of bed by now." "He shouldn't shout." "She shouldn't ignore me." Whatever yours sounds like, that's your fear part showing up. You don't need to fix it or explain it in the moment. Just notice it's there.

Then, if you can, swap it. Not for a calmer version of the same judgment, for the true thing underneath it. For me, that morning sentence has become something closer to:

When my kids are still in bed and we're cutting it fine, I panic and start shouting up the stairs. That's my fear part talking. Instead, I choose to stay connected with my kids and remember we always make the bus, my urgency is what creates the disconnect, not the time.

Yours might sound completely different, that's the point, it's your fear, not mine. But the shape holds: name the should, notice it's fear not fact, then choose the feeling you'd rather be standing in instead.

That's it. Not never feeling the should. Catching it faster each time.

If you want to go deeper on this, we spend a whole week on it inside the coaching edition.

Contact Us!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.
Don't worry, your information will not be shared.

We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.